HNC Home Page
News Business Arts & Life Sports Opinion Calendar Archive About Us
GETTING CROWDED IN THERE: Tai Wesley secures a loose ball in the Aggies' hard-fought victory over NMSU. Click the Sports Index for story and photos. / Photo by Seili Lewis

Today's word on journalism

Monday, January 14, 2008

A newspaper creed:

"An institution that should always fight for progress and reform, never tolerate injustice or corruption, always fight demagogues of all parties, never belong to any party, always oppose privileged classes and public plunderers, never lack sympathy with the poor, always remain devoted to the public welfare, never be satisfied with merely printing news, always be drastically independent, never be afraid to attack wrong, whether by predatory plutocracy or predatory poverty."

-- The New York World, 1883

News we can use: Where's the best public restroom?

By Natasha Austin

December 4, 2007 | Several years ago while living in Southeast Asia I encountered the worse public restroom of my life. When I asked a vendor in the open air market if there was a public restroom he gave me instructions to walk straight through the meat market to the end, where I would find a building that was the restroom. After walking through several stalls with animal carcasses hanging at eye level, I found the building. On the right side, painted on the brick was a picture of a woman. As I rounded the side of the building to enter, I found the building had no back wall as it was open to the hillside it was built into. In the middle of the building was one short wall that you could see over into the men's section of the restroom. There were no stalls, no toilets, no sinks, no toilet paper; just a long trough dug in the ground with a constant flow of sludge, going who knows where. And each woman squatted in a line over the trough staring at the behind of the other.

Although I will never be able to erase that memory from my mind, it seems sometimes I run into the same horrifying obstacle right here in Logan, Utah. When out and about on the town I am always plagued with the constant question of where I could stop and go and feel clean when I come out. On several occasions I have felt the urge to lather myself in Purell antibacterial hand sanitizer. This past week, I visited several public restrooms to find the cleanest and safest, and graded them accordingly.

Chevron, 400 North and Main. Grade C-
Gas stations are common 'rest' stops for most people on the road traveling and Chevron is smack dab in the middle of town, making it accessible to anyone passing through. The restroom is not located inside the gas station itself, but shares the building outside with the car wash, making it very cold this time of year. While I only observed the toilet, I can only imagine it would have been very cold to sit down. The interior of the toilet was clean, unlike the seat, but comfort that they offer protective shields. The handle was scary, and I shuddered at the thought of using it.

The mirror was covered in a black splotchy liquid that had dried on. I would be nervous washing my hands as the sink and fixture was unsightly and unclean. Be careful of using the paper towels, I suspect this could be a breeding ground for many diseases. It was covered with several different colors of grime and dirt with gunk in every open crack. There was a plastic cover sheet on the back of the door, for what I presume used to be a checklist.

Smiths MarketPlace, 700 North Main. Grade D
Hands down this was the worse restroom experience this week. Of all the overwhelming factors accounting for its low grade, the smell was the largest of them. The musty moist smell was a vivid trip down memory lane I didn't want to take, ripe and overpowering. The floor, another large contributor to the low grade, was filthy. It was not only covered in paper and garbage, but the muddy footprints everywhere, and puddles under the toilets were hard to avoid. In addition, three out of four of the stalls were low on if not missing toilet paper.

The last poor performance factor was the baby-changing station. Usually this addition to a public restroom is an appreciative and welcome site; however I would rather not change a baby here. There were numerous thick and hardened fluid stains everywhere, it clearly had not been wiped off for several days, weeks, or hard to think maybe months.

The irony of this restroom experience was leaving and catching a glimpse of the employee check list that hung on the door with the initial of the last person who cleaned the restroom at 8 p.m. I had entered the restroom approximately at 8:23, so clearly it was a blind check of the restroom. Next time, I can hold it.

Wal-Mart, 1550 North Main, North Logan. Grade B
I tried several times during the week to grade the restrooms at Wal-Mart and found myself unable to enter. The restroom was closed 'due to cleaning', a good way to start my evaluation. When I finally could visit the establishment, I found it relatively on good terms. There was no specific odor, but also void of any obvious freshener. The floor was scattered with some garbage, but was noticeably recently cleaned. Garbage was surely due to the congestion of heavy traffic encountered in the restroom, as it was the only public restroom I had to wait for.

The sinks were large and clean, with regulated water spouts. The toilets were not spotless but did not make me run, either. What I truly appreciated about this restroom was the absence of a door! Instead they have a small wall in front and you circle around the corner into the restroom. Being void of a door means I do not have to dread opening it with the handle which I know hundreds of people, who do not wash their hands, have touched. If you are in the need to stop and you are in a hurry, don't stop here, you will have to wait.

Cache Valley Mall, 1300 North Main. Grade B+
My visit to the public restroom inside the Cache Valley Mall was a pleasant surprise. The smell was fresh and clean, with no obvious hint to the purpose of the room. The garbage can was clean with a freshly changed bag. This restroom boasted several stainless steel stalls that were virtually smudge free. This was a sign it had recently been cleaned because stainless steel is hard to keep clean as it shows every little hand and fingerprint.

The best part this restroom was the array of different soaps to use, provided by Bath & Body Works. You have a choice of warm chestnut, winter apple, frosted cranberry, or holly jolly mistletoe. The downfall of this restroom was the slightly dirty counters and grimy grout on the tile throughout. Despite its downfall, it would be a safe place to stop in a hurry.

Lowe's, 313 East 1400 North. Grade A
When you want a really clean bathroom, venture a few blocks off of Main Street and use the restroom at Lowe's. I wasn't planning on grading their restroom, but a trip in for some home repair items quickly turned into a restroom evaluation. Lowe's has definitely gone 'green' with their restroom concept. Automatic lights turned on as I walked in, saving energy. They also had low-water toilets, automatic faucets, and recycled paper for toilet seat shields.

The restroom had a pleasant smell making me forget all other restrooms I had evaluated. The sinks were clean, and the mirrors spotless. The floor was impressive with warm ceramic tiles, an uncommon item found in most public restrooms. Besides its uniqueness the floor looked as if it had recently been swept and mopped. With eight stalls were clean and full of toilet paper, your choices were endless. The restroom at Lowe's also has a clean baby station, unlike its competitors.

---

When using public restrooms there is always risk involved. Next time you need to stop and use a public restroom when you're in town, use caution. Remember who made the grade, and if you can manage driving a bit off course from Main Street, Lowes is the place to go.

NW
NA

 

Copyright 1997-2008 Utah State University Department of Journalism & Communication, Logan UT 84322, (435) 797-3292
Best viewed 800 x 600.