HNC Home Page
News Business Arts & Life Sports Opinion Calendar Archive About Us
COLD FEET: Birds take to the ice as winter makes its appearance at Yellowstone National Park. / Photo by Nancy Williams

Today's word on journalism

Monday, November 5, 2007

On Objectivity:

"I still insist that 'objective journalism' is a contradiction in terms. But I want to draw a very hard line between the inevitable reality of 'subjective journalism' and the idea that any honestly subjective journalist might feel free to estimate a crowd at a rally for some candidates the journalist happens to like personally at 2,000 instead of 612 -- or to imply that a candidate the journalist views with gross contempt, personally, is a less effective campaigner than he actually is."

-- Hunter S. Thompson, from Fear & Loathing: CORRECTIONS, RETRACTIONS, APOLOGIES, COP-OUTS, ETC., a 1972 memo to Rolling Stone editor Jann S. Wenner, excerpted in the current (November 2007) issue of Harper’s Magazine (Thanks to alert WORDster Andy Merton)

Get rid of unsightly mud paths on campus

By G. Christopher Terry

October 1, 2007 | Boy, if there is one thing that really grinds our gears, it is the boneheaded shortsightedness of the landscape architecture / environmental planning firm USU seems to hire for every radical landscaping project it undertakes on campus.

The new library and the Champ Drive re-imagination are merely the most recent examples of supposedly professional LA/E planners plopping down lush swards of green grass peppered with baby saplings precisely where students want to walk. Then, months later, after an ragged muddy furrow has been slashed across the grass by thousands of students' feet, USU grounds maintenance puts up "keep off the grass" signs on metal posts. Ooooh, don't scare us.

Let's get down to the brass tacks of reality. Students are a rationally self-interested group, with a strong emphasis on the self-interest. If we are late for class, or even if we just want to check our e-mail, we are not going to walk all the way around this annoying little concession to green space on campus just because some jerk in an office somewhere said so.

Roberto Leo, a senior majoring in LA/EP here at Utah State, said adaptive solutions to the muddy problem could be integrated into the landscape of our campus as design elements. A network of curving cobblestone walkways would surely be more aesthetically pleasing than a spiderweb of angry ruts. It would keep student's shoes looking correct, too.

"The main reason of design is where people walk," Leo said. He also said stone or pebble paths "could be used as a form of design, definitely."

So there you have it, straight from an expert. I am as certain that Leo is correct as I am that the grounds crews are sick and tired of closing off marred lawns with rebar stakes and string. One solid summer of work would give our campus a direly needed facelift, and put a stop to the battle of wills between students who use the campus every day and landscape planners who are divorced from reality.

Leo said landscape architecture does not exist in a vacuum. "If you guys as students go to them and say they should throw in a design element because people are walking there, they could implement that."

Well put.

NW
RB

Copyright 1997-2007 Utah State University Department of Journalism & Communication, Logan UT 84322, (435) 797-3292
Best viewed 800 x 600.